How Long Does It Take a Gap to Fill? Surprising SPY Data on 1,967 Gaps

How Long Does It Take a Gap to Fill? Surprising SPY Data on 1,967 Gaps
How long does it take a gap to fill: two hourglasses with sand running, illustrating SPY gap fill time

“Gaps always fill” is half a rule. It skips the part that matters to anyone holding a position: how long does it take a gap to fill? A gap that fills by lunch and a gap that fills eighteen months later both count as “filled.” Only one of them helps a trader who held overnight.

We have already looked at same-day gap-fill rates by size bucket and at how Monday gaps compare with the rest of the week. This study adds the missing dimension, time. We measured how many sessions each SPY gap took to fill, and we listed the unfilled gaps that never came back.

Method: Counting Sessions Until the Prior Close Trades Again

  • Data: SPY daily open, high, low and close from Yahoo Finance’s SPY price history, January 4, 2016 through October 20, 2026.
  • Gap: the open compared with the prior session’s close, adjusted for dividends so ex-dividend days do not show up as false down-gaps. Opens within 0.10% of the prior close were treated as flat and left out.
  • Fill: the first session, starting with the gap day, in which the regular-session low (for up-gaps) or high (for down-gaps) reached the prior close.
  • Sample: the 1,967 gaps from January 2016 through September 2025. Gaps after that were cut so every gap in the tables had at least a year to fill.

This is a descriptive study, not a backtest. We did not optimize or test any strategy, and anyone with a free daily price history can reproduce the numbers.

How Long Does It Take a Gap to Fill? Cumulative Rates by Horizon

Filled by…All gaps (1,967)Up-gaps (1,141)Down-gaps (826)
Close of the gap day55.0%52.9%57.7%
Close of the next session67.0%63.5%71.7%
Within 5 sessions80.7%76.8%86.1%
Within 20 sessions88.8%84.6%94.6%
Within 60 sessions92.7%88.9%97.9%
By Oct. 20, 202696.7%94.4%100%
Never filled64 gaps64 gaps0 gaps
Source: Yahoo Finance daily SPY data, SpyTomorrow calculations. Gaps of 0.10% or more, Jan. 2016 to Sep. 2025.

Read down the first column and the “gaps always fill” story holds up: 96.7% did fill eventually. Read across the first row and it falls apart. Close to half of all gaps had not filled by the end of the session they opened in. That is the only window that matters for a one-night hold.

So how long does it take a gap to fill when it misses the first day? Among those gaps, the median wait was three sessions. Most late fills happen within a week. The slow ones are very slow, though.

Why Every Unfilled Gap Pointed Up

All 64 unfilled gaps in the sample were up-gaps. Every down-gap filled eventually. That can look like a law of nature, but it mostly reflects the decade we measured. SPY went from about $200 in early 2016 to about $770 today. In a market trending up, a down-gap gets recovered as prices move higher, and an up-gap can be left behind for good.

The unfilled gaps cluster in strong trending stretches: the post-election run in late 2016, the April–May 2020 rebound, the first week of November 2020, the November 2022 rally after the CPI report and the April–May 2025 recovery. Those were moments when the market repriced and did not look back.

A down-gap that “always fills” can take a very long time. The down-gap on January 18, 2022 (-1.07%) needed 376 sessions, about a year and a half, before SPY traded back to the prior close.

Several other down-gaps from the 2022 bear market needed roughly 200 to 325 sessions. A trader who bought one of those opens expecting the fill was not looking at a coin flip. They were looking at a full bear market’s worth of drawdown before the rule paid out. In a sustained downtrend, expect this asymmetry to reverse.

Bigger Gaps Run on a Slower Clock

Gap sizeGapsSame dayNext sessionWithin 5Within 20Never filled
0.10%–0.50%1,27366.1%75.6%86.8%92.2%1.9%
0.50%–1.00%46636.1%52.8%72.1%85.0%3.9%
1.00% and larger22831.6%47.4%64.0%77.2%9.6%
Cumulative fill rates by absolute gap size. Same data and method as above.

Size changes how long it takes a gap to fill, not only the same-day odds. A gap of 1% or more filled within a week only about two-thirds of the time, and nearly one in ten never filled. Big gaps tend to come with real news. Real news gets priced in, not undone.

After a Gap Survives Its First Day, the Odds Reset

For anyone tempted to hold a losing gap-fade “until it fills,” this is the most useful cut in the study. Here are only the 886 gaps that were still open at the closing bell:

Gaps unfilled after day oneFill next sessionWithin 5Within 20Within 60
All (886)26.6%57.1%75.1%83.7%
Up-gaps (537)22.5%50.7%67.2%76.4%
Down-gaps (349)33.0%67.0%87.1%95.1%
Conditional fill rates for gaps still open at the end of the gap day.

At the open, a gap has roughly a 55% chance of filling that day. Once it gets through the session, the chance of filling the next day falls to about one in four. An up-gap that held all day was close to a coin flip to fill within a week, and roughly one in four was still open three months later. The data does not support holding on to a failed fade.


What This Changes in an Overnight Plan

  1. Put a time limit on any fill thesis. If the trade depends on a gap filling, write down the session by which it has to happen. In this data, most of the edge was used up after day one.
  2. Size for the gaps that don’t come back. One in ten 1%-plus gaps never filled. Your position size has to survive that tail, and a stop does not guarantee the exit price you expect. See our breakdown of how stops behave across an overnight gap.
  3. Treat “eventually” as a regime bet. Down-gaps filling 100% of the time is a fact about 2016–2025. It is not a promise about the next ten years.
  4. Check your own process the same way. SpyTomorrow’s pressure readings come with a public archive and hit rate for this reason: a pre-committed view, scored afterward, shows you what actually happened instead of what you remember.

The honest answer to “how long does it take a gap to fill” is usually the same day, often within a week, occasionally more than a year, and sometimes never. A plan that only covers the first answer is not finished.

This article is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice, investment recommendations, or a solicitation to buy or sell any securities. Past performance and historical data do not guarantee future results. All trading involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Always do your own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making trading decisions.